The Watson Weekly is sponsored by Avalara — the agentic AI platform automating global tax and compliance for leading eCommerce brands with simple plans, transparent pricing, and complete coverage across Shopify, Stripe, WooCommerce, BigCommerce, and more.

Kohl's reported its 18th consecutive quarter of declining comps on Wednesday and framed the result as progress, a characterization the numbers mostly support. Net sales fell less than 1% to $3.3B and comps fell less than 1%. Full-year guidance moved up to flat-to-down-1.5% from flat-to-down-2%, and the adjusted operating margin range went to 3.5% to 4% from 2.8% to 3.4%.

Sephora at Kohl's fell 4% in the quarter, its second consecutive decline, and Fitch Ratings puts the format at roughly 10% of the department store's topline. Fitch's read is that the format drove growth until recently, so this is the second quarter running that a tenth of Kohl's revenue has worked against it.

Circana reported prestige beauty up 7% in the first half of the year, above $17B, with mass beauty also up 7% and above $39B. The category expanded 7% while the Kohl's version of it contracted 4%, and an eleven-point gap says nothing about consumer appetite for beauty and everything about where that appetite gets spent.

CEO Michael Bender attributed the decline to thin newness and a soft skin care quarter, with fragrance, hair care, and makeup holding up. He expects the weakness to continue until Kohl's can "reach full scale with new brands and cycle through the headwinds from expanded distribution from a few of the bigger brands."

Expanded distribution is doing more work in that sentence than the new brands are. The brands that gave Sephora at Kohl's its reason to exist are now sold in more places, and the original trade was access. A customer near a suburban strip center could buy prestige beauty without driving to a mall. Strip out the scarcity and Kohl's is competing on assortment and price against Ulta, Amazon and the brands' own DTC sites, where it holds no particular advantage.

Gross margin expanded 305 basis points to 43% with help from roughly $150M in tariff refunds. Against $3.3B in sales that refund is worth about 450 basis points, more than the entire expansion it is credited with helping. Kohl's says the money is headed to inventory reduction, vendors and price cuts rather than dropping through to the bottom line, and net income still fell 1% to $151M.

Private label comps grew 3%, the only line in the report Kohl's fully owns. No brand partner can widen the distribution of Kohl's own labels out from under it, which is the structural argument for private brands and the reason they sit at the center of the turnaround. Kohl's did not disclose what share of sales they now represent.

For holiday, Sephora at Kohl's is adding gift set outposts in 130 stores and fragrance towers in 250 stores in November, concentrating square footage in the one part of the category still growing.

Whether that fixes a problem Bender himself described as distribution depends on those brands staying harder to find somewhere else. Nothing in this quarter suggests they will.